Everything becomes blurry when Vick is moving on the field, including our rankings
Photo Credit: Matthew Straubmuller
Four fantasy football gurus, one set of rankings. Each of us were asked to submit their Top 32 Quarterbacks and that's exactly what we did (except for Justin, he sumbitted 31 and Tim Tebow). If there are any significant differences in our rankings we'll settle the beef in a public forum for all to see. To the jump.
|| Sept. 6
|Peyton Manning||11||4||5||7||7 (6.75)|
|Matt Schaub||9||8||9||8||8 (8.50)|
|Matt Ryan||8||9||11||9||9 (9.25)|
|Ben Roethlisberger||12||10||8||10||10 (10.0)|
|Joe Flacco||14||12||12||15||13 (13.3)|
|Josh Freeman||16||13||15||11||14 (13.8)|
|Jay Cutler||15||14||14||16||15 (14.8)|
|Sam Bradford||13||17||16||17||16 (15.8)|
|Kevin Kolb||19||16||19||12||17 (16.5)|
|Kyle Orton||17||19||18||19||18 (18.3)|
|Donovan McNabb||22||20||22||25||22 (22.3)|
|Chad Henne||23||29||24||23||24 (24.8)|
|Colt McCoy||28||27||26||21||25 (25.5)|
|Matt Hasselbeck||30||25||28||30||29 (28.3)|
Everyone's argument against Vick is injury risk, but doesn't every single player in the NFL face a huge injury risk? A Rod could go down Week 2, A.P. could go down Week 4, etc...
@Jeagle Turns out I had added the numbers correctly, just hit the 5 key instead of the 6 with Rodgers. Still rocking the 3.50 rank
@Jeagle Oh damn. I must have messed that up when editing. I'll fix soon. Thanks for the heads up.
Yes every player in the NFL is a huge injury risk, but some guys are simply at greater risk for injury than others. Vick's one of those guys. He's never stayed healthy enough to play a full season his entire career and his style of play leads to injury, there's really no disputing it. Despite the fact that he probably won't play a full slate of games, he's still ranked as a top 3 option. His upside is the top overall player in fantasy, but ignore the injury risk at your own peril...